I’ve been an Agatha Christie fan since my elementary school librarian turned me on to her novels. I’ve been thrilled that Kenneth Branagh has been bringing the stories to the big screen as both actor and director since 2017. However, I’ve also felt the last two films results were a bit of a mixed bag for various reasons. Still, with this new original adaptation of the Agatha Christie novel Halloween Party I went into A Haunting in Venice with high hopes that the third time would be the charm and Branagh would’ve successfully cracked the code on delivering a great Agatha Christie movie.
Point of fact. A Haunting in Venice is again a mixed bag for me.
The pros.
Good cast. Strong acting by Branagh (easily his best turn as Poirot to date) and Jude Hill (Belfast). Wonderful cinematography. Terrific set design. Location, location, location! Top notch atmospherics capture the supernatural, brooding darkness perfectly.
The cons.
Much like the last two films, A Haunting in Venice is a slow burner that’s an absolute slough to get through at least the first third if not half of the film. From the beginning I was barely engaged and really struggled to not only be interested but stay awake. Like Death on the Nile, it took ages for the first body to drop and the movie to get going.
For such a good cast, the bulk of them are underused and feel wasted. Then there’s Tina Fey. Love her, but feel she was miscast in her role of Ariadne Oliver. Her performance came across as more of a SNL skit version of the character.
The overuse of jump scares becomes silly and undercuts the overall eerie disquiet the film creates. There’s also an overall lack of energy to this one that pulls the entire production down.
The mystery and the clues to solve it are fairly obvious this go round so the “whodunit” aspect is fairly weak. What's the fun in that?
At the end of the day, A Haunting in Venice is a good effort and mildly entertaining but isn’t a film you need to get to the theater to see. It should be available for home viewing before long, check it out then.
A Haunting in Venice gets a 5 from me.