This weeks’ trip to the theater had me checking out the latest Disney live-action adaptation The Little Mermaid. I remember reading the story as a kid and like so many, absolutely love the 1989 animated version so I’ve been looking forward to seeing this take for the last couple of years. As I do with every film I see, I went in with an open mind and hopes for a positive movie experience. However, despite my best efforts to ignore, avoid, and otherwise tune out all the “controversy” and haterade, I also went in with a large pit in my stomach and a sense of dread instead of excitement. I wanted/needed this one to be good.
Disney’s live-action remakes have been hit or miss to put it kindly. They’ve been really good or total garbage, nothing in between. While The Little Mermaid didn't blow me away it has bucked that trend, so yay! The Little Mermaid (2023) is a solid and overall enjoying film. It’s also a mixed bag.
The expansion of the story by fleshing out Eric’s character and motivations is a welcome change as is giving Ariel more depth in hers as well. However, with a running time clocking in at 2 hours and 15 minutes there’s definite room to cut things. The Little Mermaid (2023) is too long. I never tuned out, but I did get antsy and felt the film dragged in places. The younger kids in the audience certainly got squirmy as well.
One of the most beloved aspects from the animated is the Alan Menken and Howard Ashman soundtrack. With Menken returning and the addition of Lin-Manuel Miranda I once again had high expectations. I hate to admit it, but again it was a mixed bag. Bailey has a beautiful singing voice and while I got actual chills when she belts out Part of Your World there are a few spots I wanted her to rein it in a bit. And having her sing during Under the Sea not only undercut the song thematically, frankly it messed it up for me. The Scuttlebutt I can go either way on. It’s a bit of fun, but really unnecessary and easily can go. Kiss the Girl remains stellar. Eric’s Wild Uncharted Waters...wow. The politest way I can put it is, it’s a hard pass.
The casting for the most part is strong. Halle Bailey, Jonah Hauer-King, and Javier Bardem deliver strong performances as Ariel, Eric, and King Triton. Kudos all around. For me it’s Melissa McCarthy’s Ursula and Daveed Diggs’ Sebastian that had really big shoes to fill and definitely delivered bang for the buck. Awkwafina and Jacob Tremblay didn’t add much to the mix. Scuttle and Flounder are "just there" in a more limited capacity this time around.
Great direction, wonderful costumes, and overall good visuals with a few hitches. Speaking of the visuals, I do want to know what the deal was with the Ursula/Ariel/Eric showdown. I don’t know if it was the print of the film I was viewing or an intentional decision, but I went from watching a Disney film to something straight out of DC. Things went dark. Literally. Super-sized Ursula in all her evil glory can barely be seen in the lighting, clouds, and rain. A disappointment for sure.
This is not your childhood The Little Mermaid. It’s an updated, expanded, inclusive, retelling of the classic Hans Christian Andersen tale. There’s nothing wrong with that.
Just like the original story the 1989 animated movie still exists and can continued to be enjoyed. The Little Mermaid (2023) isn’t perfect but has its merits, is enjoyable and entertaining. I do have my issues with the film, but I’m also glad I took the time to go see it in the theaters.
I’m giving The Little Mermaid (2023) a 7.
#thelittlemermaid